Google's JavaScript Indexing Myths Debunked by Vercel and MERJ Research

August 01, 2024 at 10:24:31 AM - Trending 🔥

TL;DR MERJ and Vercel's research analyzed over 100,000 Googlebot fetches to debunk myths about Google's JavaScript rendering. Findings show Google can render and index JavaScript content effectively, treats JS-heavy pages similarly to static ones, and rendering queues have minimal SEO impact. Recommendations include optimizing performance, using server-side rendering for critical SEO elements, and maintaining updated sitemaps for efficient crawling and indexing.

Google's JavaScript Indexing Myths Debunked by Vercel and MERJ Research

MERJ and Vercel conducted a comprehensive study to understand how Google handles JavaScript throughout the indexing process. This research aimed to debunk common myths and provide empirical evidence on Google's rendering capabilities.

Evolution of Google's Rendering Capabilities

  • Pre-2009: Limited support for JavaScript, primarily indexing static HTML.
  • 2009-2015: Introduction of the AJAX crawling scheme, requiring HTML snapshots for dynamic content.
  • 2015-2018: Early JavaScript rendering using a headless Chrome browser.
  • 2018-Present: Modern rendering capabilities with an up-to-date Chrome version, supporting universal rendering, stateless rendering, and asset caching.

seo javascript

Methodology

The study analyzed over 100,000 Googlebot fetches using Vercel’s infrastructure and MERJ’s Web Rendering Monitor (WRM) technology. Data was collected from sites like nextjs.org, monogram.io, and basement.io, focusing on Googlebot's behavior.

Myth 1: "Google Can't Render JavaScript Content"

Findings:

  • Google successfully rendered 100% of HTML pages, including those with complex JavaScript interactions.
  • Dynamically loaded content via API calls was indexed.
  • Next.js framework and React Server Components (RSCs) were fully rendered.

Myth 2: "Google Treats JavaScript Pages Differently"

Findings:

  • Google renders pages with or without JavaScript equally.
  • Pages with 200 status codes were rendered, while those with 3xx, 4xx, and 5xx errors were not.
  • Noindex meta tags in the initial HTML prevented rendering, regardless of JavaScript content.
  • No significant difference in rendering success rate based on JavaScript complexity.

Myth 3: "Rendering Queue and Timing Significantly Impact SEO"

Findings:

  • Median rendering delay was 10 seconds, with 75th percentile at 26 seconds and 90th percentile at ~3 hours.
  • URLs with query strings experienced longer rendering delays.
  • Frequently updated sections had shorter rendering times.

image.png

Myth 4: "JavaScript-Heavy Sites Have Slower Page Discovery"

Findings:

  • Google discovered and crawled links in fully rendered pages, regardless of rendering method.
  • Links in non-rendered JavaScript payloads were discovered.
  • Server-rendered pages had a slight advantage in immediate link discovery.
  • Updated sitemap.xml reduced time-to-discovery differences.

Overall Implications and Recommendations

Implications:

  • Google can render and index JavaScript content effectively.
  • No fundamental difference in processing JavaScript-heavy pages vs. static HTML.
  • Rendering queue impact is less significant than believed.
  • JavaScript-heavy sites are not disadvantaged in page discovery.

Recommendations:

  • Use JavaScript frameworks but prioritize performance.
  • Implement error boundaries in React applications.
  • Use server-side rendering for critical SEO elements.
  • Ensure critical resources are not blocked by robots.txt.
  • Update sitemap.xml regularly.
  • Monitor using Google Search Console.

Moving Forward with New Information

Different rendering strategies have varying impacts on crawl efficiency, discovery, rendering completeness, and indexing. However, Google will index sites effectively regardless of the rendering method, emphasizing the importance of performance and user experience. Rendering Strategies:

Feature Static Site Generation (SSG) Incremental Static Regeneration (ISR) Server-Side Rendering (SSR) Client-Side Rendering (CSR)
Crawl Efficiency Excellent Excellent Very Good Poor
Discovery Excellent Excellent Excellent Average
Rendering Completeness Robust Robust Robust Might Fail
Rendering Time Excellent Excellent Excellent Poor
Link Structure Evaluation After Rendering After Rendering After Rendering After Rendering, links might be missing if rendering fails
Indexing Robust Robust Robust Might not be indexed if rendering fails

Focus on creating performant web applications that benefit users, as page speed is a ranking factor and improves user experience.

By focusing on performance and adhering to best practices, developers can ensure their applications are effectively indexed by Google. For more details, check out the full analysis on Vercel's website below.

Have more questions on this topic? Ask our AI assistant for in-depth insights.

The Only Digital Marketing Feed You'll Ever Need.

Stay informed your way. Tailored updates when and how you want them. 100% Free.

10,000+ Users

500+ Sources

1000+ Tools

Or

Related Posts

Google Updates robots.txt Guidelines Clarifying Supported Fields and Format

Google Updates robots.txt Guidelines Clarifying Supported Fields and Format

Google Search Central
Google Search Central

Official Source

Official Source

Google Search Central is a Official Source. The source has been verified by Swipe Insight team.

Official Source
Google Search Adds Certification Support for Product Structured Data

Google Search Adds Certification Support for Product Structured Data

Google for Developers
Google for Developers

Official Source

Official Source

Google for Developers is a Official Source. The source has been verified by Swipe Insight team.

Official Source
Google Lens Introduces New Shopping Features

Google Lens Introduces New Shopping Features

Google
Google

Official Source

Official Source

Google is a Official Source. The source has been verified by Swipe Insight team.

Official Source
Top-Notch Google Analytics Audit Tool

Top-Notch Google Analytics Audit Tool

Sponsored
GA4 Auditor
GA4 Auditor

Verified Sponsor

Verified Sponsor

GA4 Auditor is a Verified Sponsor. Want to get featured here? Contact us.

Verified Sponsor
Chrome Launches CrUX Vis for Site Performance Insights

Chrome Launches CrUX Vis for Site Performance Insights

Google Retires 'noarchive' Robots Meta Tag Rule

Google Retires 'noarchive' Robots Meta Tag Rule

Google for Developers
Google for Developers

Official Source

Official Source

Google for Developers is a Official Source. The source has been verified by Swipe Insight team.

Official Source
Google Updates Guidelines for Product Markup in Search Results

Google Updates Guidelines for Product Markup in Search Results

Google for Developers
Google for Developers

Official Source

Official Source

Google for Developers is a Official Source. The source has been verified by Swipe Insight team.

Official Source
Microsoft Expands Bing with AI-Powered Generative Search for Complex Queries

Microsoft Expands Bing with AI-Powered Generative Search for Complex Queries

Microsoft
Microsoft

Official Source

Official Source

Microsoft is a Official Source. The source has been verified by Swipe Insight team.

Official Source

Related Tools

GA4 Auditor logo

GA4 Auditor

Verified Tool

Verified Tool

GA4 Auditor is a Verified Tool. Want to get this badge? Contact us.

Verified Tool

Automated GA4 audits with actionable insights

Get Featured Here

Showcase your tool in this list.

Contact Us
Surfer SEO logo

Surfer SEO

SEO content creation and optimization made easy

SEO
Sitebulb logo

Sitebulb

Efficient website crawler for better SEO audits

SEO
Screpy logo

Screpy

AI-Powered SEO and Web Analysis Simplified

SEO
Blogify logo

Blogify

Convert multimedia to SEO-optimized blogs fast

SEO
Answer the Public logo

Answer the Public

Unlock Consumer Insights for Content Creation

SEO
Ahrefs logo

Ahrefs

SEO tools to boost traffic and rank higher

SEO
Lighthouse logo

Lighthouse

Automated insights for web performance and SEO

SEO
SEO Writing AI logo

SEO Writing AI

AI-powered SEO content in 1 click

SEO
SEO Stuff logo

SEO Stuff

Affordable SEO tools without monthly fees

SEO

Get Featured Here

Showcase your tool in this list.

Contact Us